5 Surprising Truths About VPNs in an Age of Digital Regulation
23 October 2025
Just days after the UK's new Online Safety Act (OSA) came into force, requiring digital platforms to implement age verification, a surprising trend emerged. It wasn't just a debate about policy; it was a massive, measurable shift in public behavior. Millions of UK citizens reacted by seeking out privacy tools at an unprecedented rate. This wasn't just a reaction to a single law; it was an eruption of public anxiety in a country with a long and complex history of digital surveillance legislation.
Proton, a leading VPN provider, reported a "more than 1,800 per cent increase in daily sign-ups from UK-based users." At the same time, NordVPN saw a 1,000 per cent increase in UK subscription purchases. This surge reveals that as digital regulation grows, so does the public's demand for personal privacy and anonymity. But the world of VPNs is filled with counter-intuitive truths and hidden complexities. For the millions now navigating this landscape, here are five of the most surprising and impactful takeaways.
1. A Law to Protect Minors Drove an 1,800% Surge in Adult Privacy Tools
The stated goal of the Online Safety Act is to prevent under-18s from accessing harmful content, including material related to pornography, gambling, and self-harm. Yet, the law's most immediate effect was not a quiet shift in content moderation but a loud public response to perceived privacy intrusions. The data is unambiguous: the law's primary effect was not to regulate minors' access, but to trigger a massive, adult-led movement to reclaim digital privacy from the very monitoring the act required.
The new regulations pushed many users to seek out tools that could shield their identity and browsing habits from the increased monitoring required by the act. As Proton stated, the public reaction was a clear signal of adult concerns.
"This clearly shows that adults are concerned about the impact universal age verification laws will have on their privacy."
This event serves as a powerful example of how regulations, even those with benevolent intentions, can trigger the widespread adoption of privacy-enhancing technologies as citizens seek to maintain control over their data and online anonymity.
2. 'No-Logs' Doesn't Mean What You Think—Here's What Actually Matters
Nearly every major VPN service advertises a "no-logs policy," but this marketing term alone is not a guarantee of privacy. The most trustworthy providers go a step further, proving their claims through independent, third-party audits that verify their infrastructure and policies. Trustworthy providers engage in regular audits, treating privacy verification as an ongoing process, not a one-time event.
- NordVPN has undergone multiple no-logs audits over the years, conducted by independent firms including PricewaterhouseCoopers and, more recently, Deloitte, to repeatedly validate its privacy promises.
- Surfshark recently had its no-logs policy verified by the auditing firm Deloitte for a second time, reaffirming its commitment to not tracking user activity.
Here lies the counter-intuitive truth: some of the most secure VPNs do keep minimal, temporary data for essential technical reasons, which is entirely different from logging your online activity. Surfshark, for example, temporarily stores a user ID and connection timestamps, but this data is automatically deleted 15 minutes after a session ends. A company representative clarified the specific reason for this practice: "to prevent the abuse of our unlimited simultaneous connections by connecting absurd numbers of machines." This practice is considered standard in the industry for providers that offer unlimited simultaneous connections, confirming that the purpose is technical abuse-prevention, not activity monitoring.
The key takeaway for users is to look beyond the "no-logs" slogan. The real indicators of a trustworthy VPN are verifiable proof through regular audits and transparency about what minimal technical data, if any, is stored and why.
3. If You're Not Paying, You're the Product
The promise of a free VPN is tempting, but these services almost always come with a hidden cost: your personal data. A core rule of the digital economy holds true here: if you're not paying for a product, you are the product. Free VPN providers must generate revenue somehow, and they often do so by collecting and selling user data to advertisers and data brokers.
Specific free services that have been cited as problematic include Hola VPN, Betternet, and SuperVPN. It is important to distinguish these from "freemium" VPNs, which are limited free versions offered by reputable, paid providers as a way to let users test their service. For genuine privacy and security, a reputable, paid VPN with an audited no-logs policy is the only safe and reliable choice.
4. Your VPN's Speed Depends on a Single Word: WireGuard
Most users simply click "connect" and expect their VPN to work, but the underlying technology—the VPN protocol—has a massive impact on performance, especially speed and stability. The modern industry standard is a protocol called WireGuard.
With only about 4,000 lines of code, WireGuard presents a tiny attack surface compared to older protocols like OpenVPN, which can have hundreds of thousands of lines. For security experts, this simplicity is a radical advantage: a smaller, cleaner codebase is far easier to audit and secure. Top providers have even built their own optimized versions on this foundation. For instance, NordVPN created NordLynx, a custom implementation of WireGuard that provides a more stable and faster connection.
This modern technology is why today's best VPNs can handle high-bandwidth activities like streaming and gaming with significantly lower latency. In performance tests conducted by CyberInsider on a 1,000 Mbps connection, NordVPN using the WireGuard-based NordLynx protocol achieved speeds reaching as high as 903 Mbps, demonstrating its exceptional performance.
5. Never Pay Full Price: The First Rule of VPNs Is Don't Auto-Renew
The VPN industry's pricing model is built around a common strategy: monthly plans are expensive, while long-term plans spanning one or two years come with massive introductory discounts. However, as savvy users on platforms like Reddit have discovered, there's a catch—auto-renewal prices are often significantly higher than the initial promotional rate.
This has led to a clear, actionable strategy for getting the best price:
- Sign up for a long-term promotional deal to lock in the lowest monthly rate.
- Immediately go into your account settings and cancel the auto-renewal. Your service will remain active for the full period you paid for.
- When your subscription is about to expire, look for a new promotional deal—either from the same provider or a competitor—and sign up again.
As one Reddit user advised, "Make sure you don't renew after two years (cancel) then pick up another promo pack... Bottom line don't let it auto renew." While VPN companies are selling a service, users can be smart consumers by understanding these pricing games and ensuring they always get the best deal.
Conclusion: The New Price of Privacy
The surge in VPN adoption following the UK's Online Safety Act wasn't a fleeting trend; it signaled a permanent shift in public consciousness. Digital privacy is no longer an abstract concern, but a tangible commodity citizens are actively seeking to protect. However, choosing the right tool requires looking past marketing slogans to understand the real-world importance of third-party audits, the impact of underlying technology, and the realities of different business models. Being a savvy digital citizen means understanding the nuances of the tools you use to protect yourself. As our digital lives become more regulated, it's worth asking: who do you trust to protect your privacy, and what are you willing to do to safeguard it?
